UNSAFE VS UNCOMFORTABLE: WHAT CAN I TOLERATE?

Many of us are bombarded by opinions, flyers, and headlines about political issues. Even when we try to avoid them! I am going to share a few headlines that I have seen recently.

Facilitator note: The sample headlines below can be adjusted. They are meant to provoke the people in the room in a gentle, uncomfortable way but should not be activating or violent (i.e. no mention of sexual assault). You may want to adjust the examples below given the learners you work with. After you read each headline, pause and share the reflection prompts below.

Sample Headlines:

1.  Jews have no legitimate claim to the land of modern-day Israel. A two-state solution is already a major concession made by the Palestinians.

2. Gaza should be emptied of Palestinians and Israel should resettle the territory.

3. Rabbis call for the US to stop transfer of weapons to Israel.

4. Peace is impossible until Palestinian refugees let go of their demand to “return” to Israel

5. The Bible says Israel belongs to the Jews – and has for 3,000 years

Facilitator prompts learners to reflect privately after each headline:

• How do you feel after hearing that headline? 
• Notice your breathing and your heart rate.
• How do your muscles feel? When do they tense? When do they feel relaxed?
• What words come to your mind? What images?

After reading all headlines, facilitator prompts a full group conversation:

• So what did we just experience? 
• How are you feeling after hearing all of those headlines, as opposed to just one?
• Which headlines felt hardest – or maybe even intolerable – to hear? How could you tell?

On the Identity/Crisis podcast, Yehuda Kurtzer created a framework that can help us think through these and other statements about the war in Israel. 

He said: “[There are] those [ideas] that make us unsafe and those that make us uncomfortable. And then within the category of the uncomfortable, those that make us unproductively uncomfortable and those types of incidents that produce productive discomfort.” 

He goes on to say that unsafe and productive discomfort have distinctions: The former has a clear negative outcome. This might be mental health challenges or physical violence. The latter has a clear positive outcome which may include engaging in calm conversations around ideas you do not agree with, but seeing a validity in a new perspective, or the ability to condemn something yet contextualize it as non-threatening.

When we open ourselves up to uncomfortable ideas, it can feel vulnerable – like we are exposing ourselves to harm. Yet, think about when you started a new type of exercise or physical activity. The first few times you did it, it likely felt difficult. You may have been sore, and maybe you thought, “I am no good at this, I should give up!” After some practice, it may have started to feel easier. We get stronger and more flexible with practice.

We inherently have to let down some walls of protection and push ourselves in order to benefit from the growth that comes from vulnerability. Researcher and storyteller, Brené Brown says “vulnerability is the cradle of the emotions and experiences that we crave. It is the birthplace of love, belonging, joy, courage, empathy, and creativity.”

And yet, we all have our edge points – the boundary where the productive discomfort becomes unproductive or even unsafe, where we open ourselves to physical injury or emotional harm.

The main practice of the Jewish holiday of Sukkot, which is celebrated in the fall and connected to the agricultural harvest season, is to build a sukkah. A sukkah is a temporary shelter meant to remind us of the temporary dwellings the Israelites built when they were wandering through the desert and evokes the vulnerability of being a “wandering” people.

Here are some of the requirements for the structure:

• A sukkah must be built under the open sky, not below a tree or other object. 
• The walls of the sukkah can be made of any material, but have to be sturdy enough to withstand ordinary wind and regular weather. 
• A sukkah cannot be taller than 20 cubits  regardless of the other dimensions (a cubit is about the length from your elbow to the tip of your middle finger).
• Enough s’chah (roof covering) should be placed upon the sukkah so there is more shade than sunlight. 
• But the s’chah should also be light enough so that large stars can be seen through at night.
• It is customary to eat every meal in the sukkah on Sukkot, even if it is slightly uncomfortable. However, if there is extreme weather, enough to cause severe discomfort or harm, it is acceptable to go inside of a house.

We are now going to dive head first into exploring our own needs around protection and comforts around vulnerability in the context of Israel. Our shared goal is to push boundaries in a healthy way, which means being honest if something goes too far. A reminder that nothing we say or do in this room impacts the situation in Israel but it does impact our dynamic as a community.

We are going to brainstorm a list of statements/ideas you have heard about Israel and the ongoing conflict. We are not making a list of what we agree with versus disagree with. Or what we think is absurd versus absolute truth. We want to generate a list of everything you have heard.

Facilitator note: Think about our opening exercise. You want to create productive discomfort. In generating at least 10 statements from different perspectives, you may need to push your group if you notice homogeneity around ideas. Some ideas that you may want to consider including:

• Using the word genocide or not doesn’t matter. Israel is clearly killing massive numbers of Palestinians. 

• The destruction of Gaza is simply a byproduct of a justified war. 

• The United States should withhold aid from the Palestinians until the hostages are freed. 

• The United States should withhold military aid from Israel until there is a ceasefire. 

• Palestinians have a historic connection and right to live on any land between the (Jordan) river and the  (Mediterranean) sea.  

• Israelis/Jews have a historic connection and right to live on any land between the (Jordan) river and the  (Mediterranean) sea.  

• North American Jews should not have a say in Israeli politics and society. 
• North American Jews are essential voices in Israeli politics and society. 

Facilitator note, leave a bit of room after each bullet point. Learners will need to put stickers next to some of them in the next step of this activity.

Now that we have brainstormed this list, I want you to think about how these statements make you feel. I am going to ask you to put a green sticker or dot next to ideas that you feel like you can hear–not necessarily what you agree with. Red stickers or dots should go next to those ideas that you feel like you cannot tolerate. They make you feel unsafe. And finally the yellow stickers or dots are for those about which you are not sure.